
Hybrids are easy on the environment and conservative on gas–a winning solution for easing pain at the pump. But there’s a catch: You may have to drive thousands of miles over several years before the savings on gas catch up to the extra expense of the car.
Of course, it all depends on which hybrid you buy, according to NADAguides.com, a vehicle pricing and information Web site, which last week announced the release of a study showing which hybrids earn their extra cost the fastest. The best cars only take a little more than a year. The worst take a bit longer. The 2008 Lexus LS600h sedan would take 1,390,850 miles to break even at Los Angeles gas prices ($4.59 per gallon). If you drive 15,000 miles per year, that’s 92.7 years.
“People buy hybrids because they want to save gas, make a small, individual impact on reducing the U.S. dependency on oil or make an individual impact on fuel emissions,” says Tara Baukus Mello, senior writer and lead market analyst for NADAguides.com. “But if you are looking to have an impact on your wallet, then buying a hybrid may not make the best financial sense.”
The best deal for a Los Angeles commuter is the $25,200 Toyota Camry hybrid that only costs $200 more than the gas-powered Camry XLE. The hybrid gets 34 mpg, and the gas model gets only 22 mpg. The owner of the hybrid breaks even after 18,292 miles. For Los Angles commuters who log 15,000 miles a year, that’s just a little over a year of driving.
Rounding out the top five hybrids with the shortest miles required to break even are No. 2 Chevrolet Malibu (32,206 miles), No. 3 Nissan Altima (37,580), No. 4 Toyota Prius (41,626) and at No. 5, the Honda Civic (57,216).
At the bottom of the list–but still the eighth most economic hybrid according to the NADAguides–is the Lexus RX400h. A Los Angeles commuter owning an RX400h and paying an average $4.59 a gallon to fill up the tank would have to drive 96,013 miles, or nearly 6.2 years at 15,000 miles a year before reaching the break-even point. A Lexus luxury hybrid SUV costs $4,180 more than the $37,400 RX350, the comparable gas-powered SUV. The only difference in combined EPA estimated fuel economy is 5 mpg; the RX400h gets 25 mpg, while the RX350 gets 20 mpg.
Behind the Numbers
NADAguides.com derived its list of hybrids that earn their cost the fastest by using EPA-estimated combined average fuel economy, current 2008 manufacturer suggested retail price for all vehicles, federal tax credits when applicable and regular unleaded per gallon gas prices for 10 metropolitan cities as of July 3 from the Energy Information Administration. Break-even points vary slightly in different parts of the country, depending on gas prices and how much driving commuters tend to do. The more time spent in the car with higher gas prices, the faster the hybrid earns out its extra cost.
Overall, California is the leading state for hybrid sales, according to R. L. Polk & Co., an automotive marketing and research company. In 2007, 26% of all hybrid registrations were in California. Los Angeles was the city in the NADAguides.com study with the shortest break-even time for hybrid owners, because drivers there spend more time on the road and have the highest gas prices ($4.59 a gallon as of July 3). Houston had the longest break-even time since drivers there commute shorter distances and have the lowest gas prices ($3.88 a gallon).
In an attempt to offset the higher premium paid for a hybrid, the federal government implemented a hybrid tax credit for up to $3,000. Once a manufacturer has sold 60,000 hybrid vehicles, the tax credit for buyers gradually phases out and eventually disappears. There are no tax credits on the Prius and Lexus hybrids as of Oct. 1, 2007; Toyota hit the 60,000 mark in 2006. Honda reached the 60,000 threshold in the third quarter of 2007. Buyers are eligible for lower tax credits through July 1, 2009.
In some instances, the tax credit offsets the premium paid for a hybrid, like the $23,640 Chevrolet Malibu that gets 27 mpg and costs $2,455 more than the gas-powered model that gets 20 mpg.